Skip to content

Free tools

ICE scoring calculator

Rate each idea for Impact, Confidence and Ease from 1 to 10. The calculator averages them into an ICE score and ranks your list, so you can pick what to try next in minutes. Free, with no sign-up.

Your ideas

Idea 1
ICE score—
Idea 2
ICE score—
Idea 3
ICE score—

Do first

—

Fill in a row to score it. Every complete row ranks here, highest first.

Ranking

Nothing scored yet.

Score a idea to export your ranking as a CSV you can import into Quackback.

What is ICE scoring?

ICE is a quick prioritization framework popularized by Sean Ellis for ranking growth experiments. Teams now use it for feature ideas too. Each idea gets three scores from 1 to 10. The glossary covers the ICE framework in more depth.

Impact

1 barely noticeable · 10 transformative

How much it will move the goal you care about, such as activation, retention or revenue.

Confidence

1 a guess · 10 proven by data

How sure you are about the impact. Data, research and customer requests all raise it.

Ease

1 months of work · 10 an afternoon

How easy it is to ship. The opposite of effort, so quick wins score high.

How to calculate an ICE score

Score the three factors, then combine them. This calculator takes the average.

ICE = (Impact + Confidence + Ease) ÷ 3

Averaging keeps every score on the same 1–10 scale as its inputs. Some teams multiply instead; the difference is explained below.
  1. Rate Impact

    How much will it move your goal? 1 is barely noticeable, 10 transforms it.

  2. Rate Confidence

    How sure are you? 1 is a hunch, 10 is backed by data or a test.

  3. Rate Ease

    How easy is it to ship? 1 is months of work, 10 is a few hours.

  4. Average and rank

    Add the three, divide by 3, and sort your ideas highest first.

Example: Annual billing discount
Impact
6
Confidence
8
Ease
9
(6 + 8 + 9) ÷ 3
7.67
ICE score
7.7

Average or multiply?

Two ideas scored by averaging and by multiplying
IdeaImpactConfidenceEaseAveragedMultiplied
Rebuild onboarding9926.7162
Pricing page test6666216

Averaging puts the ambitious idea first. Multiplying puts the steady one first, because one low score drags a product down far harder than an average. Neither is wrong: choose one method, use it for the whole list, and say which you used.

ICE vs RICE

Both rank ideas on one number. ICE trades precision for speed; RICE adds Reach and measures effort in real units.

ICE and RICE compared
ICERICE
FactorsImpact, Confidence, EaseReach, Impact, Confidence, Effort
Formula(I + C + E) ÷ 3, or I × C × ER × I × C ÷ E
Scale1 to 10 for each factorReal units for Reach and Effort
Time to scoreA minute or two per ideaLonger: needs data
Data neededLittleReach estimates and effort sizing
Best forExperiments, early ideas, long listsProduct backlogs with varied reach

How to keep ICE scores consistent

ICE is quick because it's subjective. A few habits stop it drifting.

Agree what each number meansWrite down what a 3, a 6 and a 9 look like for each factor before you start.
Tie Impact to one goalScore every idea against the same metric, such as activation or retention.
Score quickly, togetherA minute or two per idea. ICE is for speed, not debate.
Raise Confidence with evidenceCustomer requests, data or a quick test can move an idea from a 3 to a 7.
Re-score after you learnWhen an experiment ends, update the ideas it tells you about.
Size up the winnersGive the top few a full RICE score before committing serious work.

Ground Confidence in what customers ask for

Confidence is where ICE scores get fuzzy. Requests and votes on a feedback board give you evidence to score it with.

See how many customers want it, and why

Customers post ideas and vote on each other's, so you can see how many people want something and what they said about it. An idea with real demand behind it earns a higher Confidence than one from a single conversation.

  • Votes, comments and voters on every request
  • Duplicates merge, so demand isn't split
  • Post summaries from Quackback AI, on Pro and up
Explore feedback boards

Example data. What follows is an interactive demo of a made-up workspace called Acme. Its customers, posts, votes and changelog entries are examples, not Quackback's own.

Acme Corp
PN
Boards
Powered by Quackback

Common questions

What is the ICE scoring model?

ICE is a quick prioritization framework that scores each idea on three factors from 1 to 10: Impact (how much it will move your goal), Confidence (how sure you are of that) and Ease (how easy it is to do). The three combine into one ICE score you can rank ideas by.

How do you calculate an ICE score?

This calculator averages the three scores: ICE = (Impact + Confidence + Ease) ÷ 3, which keeps the result on the same 1 to 10 scale. An idea scored 6 for Impact, 8 for Confidence and 9 for Ease gets (6 + 8 + 9) ÷ 3 = 7.7.

Should ICE scores be averaged or multiplied?

Both are common. Averaging keeps scores between 1 and 10 and treats the factors as interchangeable. Multiplying (Impact × Confidence × Ease, from 1 to 1,000) punishes a low score in any one factor much harder, so the two methods can rank ideas differently. Pick one, use it for the whole list, and note which you used. This calculator averages.

What do the ICE scores from 1 to 10 mean?

For Impact, 10 transforms the metric you care about and 1 is barely noticeable. For Confidence, 10 means strong data or evidence and 1 is a guess. For Ease, 10 is a few hours of work and 1 is months of it. Agree what a 3, a 6 and a 9 look like before you start, so everyone scores the same way.

What is a good ICE score?

There's no universal cut-off; ICE is for ranking ideas against each other. As a rough guide on the averaged 1 to 10 scale, ideas around 7 or above deserve a closer look, and anything below 4 needs more evidence or a cheaper approach first.

When should I use ICE instead of RICE?

Use ICE for a fast first pass: growth experiments, early ideas, or a long list you need to cut down in one meeting. Use RICE when ideas reach very different numbers of people and you can estimate how many. Many teams screen with ICE, then give the shortlist a full RICE score.

Who created the ICE framework?

ICE was popularized by Sean Ellis, the growth marketer who coined the term growth hacking, as a fast way to prioritize growth experiments. Product teams now use it for feature ideas too.

Have another question? Talk to the team.

Run support and feedback in one place